Best Mango Lime Tart Recipe – Easy Summer Tart

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe·Leave a Review

Mango lime tart recipe, Even hearing the name brings a warm, golden feeling like a cozy hug from the sun served on a dish. At Wish-Cake.com, every dessert I share is rooted in a memory, a flavor, or a moment worth savoring. This one takes me back to the simple joys of baking beside my grandmother, where citrus peels and sticky mango fingers were part of the magic.

Those early days, spent learning how food brings people together, are what inspired me to create this space a cozy corner of the internet where sweet treats and family stories live side by side. Now, as a busy mom, baking is still my love language. It’s how I celebrate, comfort, and connect with my kids.

And this mango lime tart? It’s one of our favorites. Creamy mango filling brightened with lime juice, nestled in a buttery graham crust, and topped with a swirl of vanilla whipped cream. It’s quick, beautiful, and bursting with tropical flavor perfect for summer picnics, birthdays, or quiet Sunday afternoons.

Discover great ideas like our best mango cheesecake if you’re craving more mango magic.

Contents

1 Ingredients Breakdown for Mango Lime Tart Recipe
2 Mango Lime Tart Recipe
3 Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Mango Lime Tart
4 Mango Flavor Explained – Why Does My Mango Taste Tart?
5 Mango Preparation Tips – How to Cut Mango for Tart Recipes
6 Is Mango Supposed to Be Tart? – Mango Varieties and Flavor Profiles
7 When Not to Eat a Mango – Spoilage Signs and Safety
8 The Sweetest Mango Color – Choosing the Best Mango for Tarts
9 Conclusion – Wrapping Up the Perfect Mango Lime Tart Recipe
10 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Ingredients Breakdown for Mango Lime Tart Recipe

Detailed Look at Crust Ingredients and Their Roles

The foundation of this mango lime tart recipe is a golden, buttery graham cracker crust. It’s quick, no-fuss, and perfectly complements the tart’s creamy center.

Crushed graham biscuits (7 oz, roughly 13 pieces) form a crispy foundation with a mild touch of sweetness. You want them finely ground for a compact, sliceable crust.
Fine sea salt (pinch): A small pinch sharpens all the other flavors, preventing the crust from tasting flat.
Ground cayenne pepper (¼ teaspoon, optional): Not traditional, but it adds a gentle warmth that contrasts beautifully with the Mango Lime Tart sweet filling.
Unsalted butter (5 tablespoons, melted): This binds the crumbs together and gives the crust richness and structure once baked.

Key Components of the Mango Lime Filling

This filling is where the mango lime tart recipe truly comes alive—creamy, fruity, tangy, and smooth. The secret? Using fresh mango puree and balancing it with just the right touch of lime.

Fresh mango (1 pound, about 3 medium): Choose ripe, soft mangoes for natural sweetness. After pureeing and straining, you’ll get about 1 cup of silky puree.
Lime juice (6 tablespoons): Fresh-squeezed is a must. It sharpens the mango’s tropical notes and brings a needed brightness.
Egg yolks (4, at room temperature): These provide structure, creaminess, and help the filling set during baking.
Sweetened condensed milk (1 14oz can): Adds sweetness and body to the Mango Lime Tart. Its thick consistency balances the tart lime juice.
A pinch of fine sea salt (½ tsp) balances the taste, preventing the citrus from being overwhelmed by sugar.
Amoretti Natural Mango Artisan Flavor (2 tablespoons): Optional but recommended. It brings out a richer mango flavor, which is particularly helpful when the fruit hasn’t fully ripened.

Whipped Topping Elements and Optional Garnish Suggestions

Placing a spoonful of whipped cream on the Mango Lime Tart adds a light sweetness, softening the tart’s bright citrus flavors with a smooth, creamy touch.

Heavy whipping cream (1 cup): Whips into a fluffy, smooth topping that complements the Mango Lime Tart filling without overpowering it.
Powdered sugar (2 tablespoons): Sweetens the cream just enough without making it dense.
½ teaspoon of vanilla extract infuses a delicate aroma, harmonizing beautifully with the bright flavors of lime and mango.
Thin strips of lime skin, used as a garnish, add a bright splash of color and a refreshing citrus aroma.
Mango slices or edible flowers (optional): For decoration, these bring visual appeal and hint at the tropical flavors within.

In the next section, we’ll walk through every step of making this delicious Mango Lime Tart from crust to cream.

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Mango Lime Tart

Preparing the Graham Cracker Crust Correctly

Start with your crust, because it’s the base that holds the whole tart together. The secret? Finely crushed crumbs and even pressure.

Preheat your oven to 350°F.
Crush the graham crackers using a food processor until you get a fine, sandy texture. No big chunks should remain.
Add the salt and optional cayenne pepper to the crumbs and pulse to combine. Cayenne adds a mild heat that gently lingers, without turning up the spice.
Drizzle the warm butter into the bowl, then mix just enough so everything feels evenly moistened. The mixture should hold its shape when pressed between your fingers.
Spoon the blend into a 9-inch tart pan or pie plate, then press it flat and up the edges using the underside of a measuring cup for an even finish.
Bake the crust for 8–10 minutes, or until it starts turning golden and smells toasty. Allow it to cool for a few minutes before adding the filling.

Blending and Straining the Mango Puree for Smooth Texture

This step makes all the difference. You want your mango filling to be as silky and smooth as possible—no fibrous bits.

Peel and core your mangoes. Use a paring knife or a mango slicer. Cut off the fruit and toss the hard central seed.
Transfer the pieces of mango into your blender or food processor to start blending. Blend until completely smooth.
Press the puree through a fine mesh sieve. This step removes any pulp or strands, giving you a velvety mango base. Measure out 1 cup of the strained puree.

Baking and Cooling the Mango Lime Tart for Perfect Consistency

This part brings it all together—the mango, lime, and creaminess meld into a luscious filling.

In a large bowl, whisk the egg yolks and lime juice until well blended and slightly thickened.
Stir in the sweetened condensed milk and keep mixing until the texture is silky.
Stir in the mango puree and mango flavoring (if using). Make sure it’s well incorporated, but don’t over-whisk.
Pour the filling into the cooled crust.
Bake for 15 to 18 minutes. The edges should be set, and the center should still have a gentle jiggle—think firm Jell-O.
Cool completely on a wire rack. Then, chill in the fridge for at least 3 hours, or overnight if you want to make it ahead. The Mango Lime Tart firms up beautifully as it chills.

Once chilled, it’s ready to top with whipped cream and garnishes for that final finish.

A sliced mango lime tart recipe topped with whipped cream and lime zest, showing the creamy citrus filling and golden graham cracker crust. — This mango lime tart recipe is the ultimate citrus dessert—light, creamy, and perfect for summer celebrations or everyday indulgence.

Mango Flavor Explained – Why Does My Mango Taste Tart?

Why Mangoes Taste Mango Lime Tart Sometimes

If your mango lime tart recipe comes out more tangy than sweet, the mango may not have been fully ripe. Unripe mangoes contain more acid and less sugar, which leads to that tart flavor. A ripe mango should feel soft to the touch and smell sweet at the stem.

If your mango is too tart, you can balance it with a little extra sweetened condensed milk, honey, or even a splash of mango extract to smooth out the sharpness.

Sweet vs. Tart Mango Varieties

Some mangoes are just naturally more tart than others. For desserts, go with sweeter types like Ataulfo or Kent. They’re softer, less fibrous, and give a smoother, sweeter puree. Varieties like Tommy Atkins can be more fibrous and tangy, making them harder to work with in this tart.

Does Tart Mango Ruin the Dessert?

Not at all. A little tang can actually brighten up the creamy filling and pair well with the lime. But if you prefer a mellow tropical flavor, always taste your mango puree first and adjust the sweetness as needed.

Mango Preparation Tips – How to Cut Mango for Tart Recipes

Step-by-Step Guide to Peeling, Coring, and Slicing Mango

Properly handling mangoes ensures a silky and delicious tart filling. Because mangoes have a large, flat seed at their center, slicing them properly requires a bit of technique:

Stand the mango upright on a stable surface, resting it on its base to keep it steady.
Slice down along the sides of the pit—you’ll get two thick “cheeks.”
Using a sharp knife, gently carve a series of intersecting lines into the fruit’s surface, taking care not to pierce the skin beneath.
Use a spoon to gently lift out the fruit chunks, or flip the skin inside out to easily cut them away.
For any remaining flesh, slice around the pit and trim off usable bits.

Tip: If your mango is very ripe, it might be slippery. Use a paper towel to grip the skin while slicing to keep your hands safe.

Tools to Use for Efficient Mango Prep

Using the right tools makes prep faster and safer:

Sharp paring knife: Ideal for slicing mango cheeks and removing skin.
Using a spoon or melon baller makes it easy to remove the mango’s pulp neatly, leaving little behind.
Mango slicer (optional): These tools split the fruit from the pit and can save time if you’re prepping multiple mangoes.

Mango Yield: How Much Flesh Per Fruit?

A typical mid-sized mango usually gives you around three-quarters to a full cup of edible fruit. For this mango lime tart recipe, you’ll need about 1 pound of mango, or roughly 3 medium mangoes, to produce the required 1 cup of smooth puree after blending and straining.

Is Mango Supposed to Be Tart? – Mango Varieties and Flavor Profiles

Are Mangoes Naturally Tart?

Some mangoes are, especially if they’re under-ripe. Tartness comes from higher acid content and lower sugar levels. If your mango lime tart recipe tastes more sour than sweet, your mango may not be fully ripe.

Which Mangoes Are Best for Tarts?

Choose sweeter varieties like Ataulfo or Kent. They’re soft, less fibrous, and perfect for desserts. Tommy Atkins, while easy to find, can be more tart and fibrous, which makes them less ideal for purees.

Can Tart Mango Work in This Recipe?

Yes, in moderation. A little tartness balances the sweetness of the condensed milk and pairs well with lime. Just taste your puree before mixing, and adjust with a bit more sweetener if needed.

When Not to Eat a Mango – Spoilage Signs and Safety

Easy Ways to Check if a Mango Is Rotten

Before using mangoes in your mango lime tart recipe, make sure they’re safe and fresh. Here’s what to watch for:

Unusual Odor Warning: While a ripe mango typically has a fragrant, sweet scent, an overly sharp or acidic smell—like sour wine or vinegar—is a clear sign that it has passed its prime or has gone bad.
Mushy or blackened spots: A little softness is fine, but large dark patches or wrinkling could mean it’s breaking down.
Leaking or sticky skin: This can be a sign the mango is fermenting inside.
Mold on skin or stem area: Discard immediately.

If your mango shows any of these signs, it’s better to toss it than risk it affecting the tart’s flavor—or your health.

How to Store Mangoes Safely

Proper storage helps preserve flavor and texture:

Unripe mangoes: Leave at room temperature until they soften.
Ripe mangoes: Store in the fridge and use within 3–5 days.
Sliced Mango Storage Tip: Once cut, store mango pieces in a sealed container in the refrigerator and enjoy them within two days for best taste and freshness.

Never use mangoes that have been sitting out peeled or cut for more than two hours—especially in warm conditions.

Is It OK to Eat a Sour Mango?

A naturally sour mango isn’t harmful if it’s fresh. But if it also smells off, has a weird texture, or tastes fermented, skip it. In this tart, overly sour fruit can ruin the balance. It’s always best to use ripe, fragrant mangoes for a creamy, sweet finish.

The Sweetest Mango Color – Choosing the Best Mango for Tarts

What Color Mango Is the Sweetest?

When choosing mangoes for your mango lime tart recipe, color offers a great clue. Typically, the sweetest mangoes feature golden yellow or deep orange skin, sometimes with a slight wrinkle—especially if you’re working with Ataulfo mangoes, which are ideal for creamy desserts.

Red patches can be misleading—they’re just signs of sun exposure and don’t always mean the mango is ripe. That’s why it’s important to combine visual cues with touch and smell when picking the perfect mango for your mango lime tart.

How to Tell If a Mango Is Ripe

Here’s how to make sure your mango is just right for a mango lime tart recipe:

When you press a mature mango with light pressure, its surface should respond with a soft bounce—kind of like how a balloon gives under your hand, not too firm and not too mushy.
Smell: A sweet, fruity aroma near the stem signals perfect ripeness.
Look: Varieties like Kent or Ataulfo turn a rich yellow-orange when ready. Avoid green, firm mangoes—they’re still underripe and will make your tart taste too sour.

Mango Varieties That Deliver the Best Flavor

To get the smoothest texture and fullest flavor in your mango lime tart recipe, stick with these tried-and-true mangoes:

Variety	Texture	Flavor	Best Use
Ataulfo	Buttery, smooth	Very sweet, rich	Best for tart fillings and purees
Kent	Soft, juicy	Mild and tropical	Great for blending into creamy bases
Haden	Aromatic	Slightly tangy-sweet	Balanced mango-lime flavor

Avoid Tommy Atkins, as it tends to be fibrous and lacks the clean finish you want in a mango lime tart.

By choosing the right mango, you set the tone for a dessert that’s not only flavorful but visually stunning and texturally flawless. A great mango equals a great tart.

Conclusion – Wrapping Up the Perfect Mango Lime Tart Recipe

There’s something incredibly satisfying about pulling a perfectly chilled mango lime tart from the fridge. It’s colorful, fragrant, and rich with tropical flavors that feel like sunshine on a plate. From the buttery graham cracker crust to the creamy mango-lime filling and the soft peaks of vanilla whipped cream on top, this dessert strikes the ideal balance between tangy and sweet.

Whether you’re serving it at a backyard BBQ, bringing it to a summer potluck, or just enjoying a slice with your morning coffee, this mango lime tart recipe is easy to make and always impressive. Best of all, it brings a little bit of joy and nostalgia to your kitchen—just like the memories I’ve built around baking with my family and now share with you on Wish-Cake.com.

For More Delicious And Easy Recipes Follow Me In Facebook And Pinterest.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Why does my mango taste tart?

Mangoes taste tart when they aren’t fully ripe. Unripe mangoes have more acid and less sugar, which creates that sour punch. To avoid this in your mango lime tart recipe, choose soft, fragrant mangoes with golden or orange skin.

How to cut mango for tarte?

Stand the mango upright and slice off the two large cheeks along the flat pit. Cut shallow lines across the surface in an X-shaped grid, then lift the chunks out using a spoon. Cut around the pit for any extra flesh. Blend the chunks to use in your tart filling.

Is mango supposed to be tart?

Some mangoes are naturally more tart, especially varieties like Tommy Atkins or if they’re under-ripe. For a balanced mango lime tart, go for sweeter types like Ataulfo or Kent.

When not to eat a mango?

Avoid mangoes that smell fermented, feel mushy or slimy, leak juice, or have mold. These are signs the fruit is spoiled and not safe to eat—especially in a recipe like this where freshness is key.

What color mango is the sweetest?

The sweetest mangoes are usually golden yellow or deep orange when ripe. This mango variety tends to ripen with a bit of skin texture and delivers an intense sugary taste when fully matured. Avoid mostly green mangoes unless you plan to let them ripen at room temperature.

Is it OK to eat a sour mango?

Yes, if the mango is fresh and not spoiled, a sour one can still be eaten. However, in a dessert like this mango lime tart recipe, a sour mango can overwhelm the flavor. Always taste and adjust sweetness before baking.